Issue Archives

Public-meaning originalism—the theory that the meaning of legal texts, including the U.S. Constitution, is fixed when authoritatively adopted and binding until authoritatively changed—is ascendant. Although scholars debate this theory, a majority of U.S. Supreme Court Justices describe themselves as originalists and advocates increasingly advance arguments sounding in public-meaning originalism. And even jurists who are not originalists...

The Supreme Court’s Fourth Amendment doctrine largely ignores how race shapes police encounters. Yet over the past few decades, several state courts have rejected this approach when expounding their own constitutions, adopting more protective standards that better account for how policing actually operates.

Working backward from these departures, the Article examines the logics that persuaded state courts to diverge from federal law. It...

Federal courts apply stare decisis with extra force to decisions that interpret statutes. Critics contend that this “supercharged” deference to statutory precedent lacks a legitimate pedigree. But that charge rests on conjecture, since scholars have paid little attention to how English courts historically handled such cases. This Essay responds with a new history of statutory stare decisis. For much of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries,...

The movement to lower the voting age to sixteen confronts a constitutional trilemma. Congress cannot mandate youth enfranchisement by statute. Constitutional amendment, though doctrinally sound, requires supermajorities unattainable absent a galvanizing crisis comparable to Vietnam. Municipal experiments show promise, but state constitutional barriers and fiscal constraints prevent scaling. While the normative question—whether sixteen- and seventeen-year-olds...

Intimate partner violence (IPV) cases frequently require law enforcement to make rapid decisions at the intersection of survivor safety and Fourth Amendment privacy protections in the home. The Supreme Court’s decision in Georgia v. Randolph, which bars warrantless entry into the home based on disputed consent between co-occupants, has generated significant uncertainty when a survivor is outside the home, referred to herein as “non-exigent”...

Under 28 U.S.C. § 1782, U.S. district courts have jurisdiction to provide discovery assistance for foreign proceedings. That jurisdiction is based, in part, on whether the discovery target “resides or is found” in the relevant district. Recently, federal courts have disagreed on the standard for meeting that requirement. This Note argues that a faithful construction based on the statute’s text, Congress’s intent, and the broader system...

REINING IN RUNAWAY RECRUITING

Cecilia A. Silver* & Jamie R. Abrams **

The Big Law hiring market has run away, and everyone is paying the price. This manufactured “arms race” for talent harms students, educators, career counselors, and Big Law itself. Big Law now plays an outsized role in law school life, collaterally disrupting foundational educational processes and professional relationships that should be complementary. The cascading costs are logistical, psychological, and political. Rectifying Big Law’s...

Environmental injustice (the siting of polluting facilities) in unincorporated communities of color is not merely a result of bad actors but a foreseeable consequence produced and perpetuated by fragmented legal frameworks that delegate authority to local decisionmakers without accountability, especially in the absence of meaningful democratic representation or judicial review. The result is that county commissioners are incentivized to pursue...

QUASI-JUDICIAL: A HISTORY AND TRADITION

Beau J. Baumann* & Jed Handelsman Shugerman**

The Roberts Court transformed the debate over presidential removal with two conflicting cases. In Trump v. Slaughter, the Court overruled Humphrey’s Executor and embraced a maximalist unitary executive. It rejected the “quasi-judicial” and “quasi-legislative” categories from Humphrey’s that were the foundation for independent regulatory commissions. But in Trump v. Cook, the Court preserved removal...

Religious and parental rights are ascendant in public schools following the Supreme Court’s decision Mahmoud v. Taylor and its interim docket order Mirabelli v. Bonta. Mahmoud focused on free exercise opt-out claims as they relate to the curricular content taught in public schools, and Mirabelli expanded that rule to reach the gender transition non-disclosure policies adopted by some of those schools. This Note considers...